By Justin Yamashita, MSc. Benchtop, site, CRO: three levels of basic and clinical research, explained without spin.
New here? Root to Rx runs three pieces a week, down from five as of this issue. I manage oncology clinical trials for a living and one of my studies is going into launch, so I cut the schedule from 5 tracks rather than the standards.
“A Facebook post said measles basically vanished on its own. That the real gamble with the vaccine now.”
Martha is seventy-one. She isn't an anti-vaxxer, she's a grandmother with a phone and a granddaughter due for a second dose, and she's never once in her life seen a child with measles. That last part isn't luck. It's the exact condition this week's claim needs in order to work on her. She says it at her daughter's dinner table, to a man who reads vaccine safety reports for a living, and she has no idea that's what he does.
The Vanishing Act
Bias the Brain and Influencer Ivy team-up
Black Box Warning
Tactic: The Vanishing Act
Tool: the availability bias (heuristic)
Running it: Bias the Brain, with Influencer Ivy
This week's Black Box Warning takes two bad actors, because this trick needs a partner.
Influencer Ivy posted it with her ring light shining on her face, warm delivery, no credentials claimed and none needed, because the whole point of Ivy is that liking someone stands in for checking them.
But Ivy isn’t inside your house. She can only put a sentence on a screen with an affiliate link to click in her bio. Getting that sentence to feel like something Martha worked out herself takes an inside man. That's Bias the Brain, who has been living in there for seventy-one years and speaks in Martha's own internal voice. He has a different tool for every week. This week he's running the availability bias (called an availability heuristic), and it's the one he barely has to lift a finger for.
“You already believe me,” Bias says. “You just don't know it yet.”
He never argues. He doesn't have to. Availability is the laziest tool in his toolkit, because it works on what isn't there. Here's the three move play, and all three happen inside her head.
1. Erase the before.
Most people under fifty have never seen a measles ward or a child in an iron lung. Bias counts on that, and there's a name for what he's exploiting. The availability bias: we judge how likely something is by how easily we can call an example to mind. No mental image, no felt risk. A theoretical danger loses to a real needle every time.
Picture this. Nobody keeps a photo of the crash they didn't have. So the seatbelt becomes the annoying part of the drive and the windshield stays theoretical, and the belt is the entire reason it stayed theoretical.
2. Credit the wrong hero.
“These were already going away. It was better plumbing, not vaccines.” Clean water did enormous good and it stopped a great deal of illness. It didn't stop measles, and it didn't stop polio. The near-vertical drop in both lines up with the year the vaccines arrived, not with the pipes. But once you believe it was hygiene, you've quietly removed your own reason to keep going.
Picture this. Say you rewired the house and fitted smoke alarms the same year, and a decade later nothing has burned down. Crediting the wiring is fair enough because it did real work. But you wouldn’t pull the batteries out of the alarms because the wiring is safer.
3. Move the fear.
The disease feels gone so the credit has been reassigned. The only frightening thing left in the room is the vaccine. Notice how the fear never went anywhere. It got relocated onto the thing that emptied the room in the first place.
Picture this. A whole summer goes by and nobody drowns at the community pool. If you never saw anyone go under, the only odd thing left at that pool is the lifeguard watching everybody. The fear needs somewhere to go, but we don’t ask for the lifeguard to be removed.
Sam the Skeptic: “So who actually profits here?”
Ivy does. Ivy has an affiliate link and an outrage economy behind her, where a frightening claim about a vaccine reliably outperforms a boring reminder that it worked.
Bias works for free. That's what makes him the dangerous one, but also the one we have the most potential control over. And it means neither of them actually needs to convince Martha of anything. They need somebody at that table to lose their temper.
Two versions of the next ninety seconds
Theo has been married to Martha's daughter for nine years, and he works in drug safety, which means he's read more vaccine adverse event reports than almost anyone she'll ever meet. He knows the facts cold.
What follows are two versions of the same ninety seconds. The facts are identical in both. Everything that matters is different.
Option A. He corrects her.
And he's right about every word. Eliminated in 2000, but more than two thousand cases last year, with three deaths. Coverage down in exactly the counties where it came back. He has the receipts and he produces them.
Martha stops talking about four sentences in. Not because she's persuaded. Because she's worked out that she's being graded, at her own daughter's table, by a man half her age, in front of her family.
She says something light so nobody feels awkward. She leaves before dessert.
At home she opens her phone, and the post is still sitting there. Now it’s the only thing in her entire day that didn't make her feel stupid so she shares it. Over the next month she shares four more, and two of them are worse than the first.
Theo won that argument. Every fact he said was correct and he could source all of it.
And Ivy just picked up a distributor she didn't have to pay for.
Option B. Rewind, Stay in the room.
Same table, same sentence, same man who knows the same things. Watch what he does instead, because it's a technique and you can steal it. It’s the one-two punch that’s actually pulling punches, using the OPEN and PAUSE cards.
First he checks himself with “am I here to help her, or am I here to win?” He wants to win. He notices that he wants to win, and he pulls the verbal punch. That's the hardest move in this whole newsletter and it happens entirely inside his own head, where nobody can applaud it.
Then he asks what she's actually worried about. Not what she read, what she's frightened of.
It takes her a while to get there. It isn't measles. It's Nora, four years old, due for a second dose, and Martha sitting with the feeling that she'd be the one who let something happen to her having seen scary posts about vaccine injuries on Facebook.
“Where'd you see it?” Not as a trap. He wants to look at the same thing she looked at. She turns the phone around and they read it together, which is a completely different act from arguing about it.
Then he says something true that costs him something. “I don't want anything to happen to Nora either. That's not me being nice. That's literally my job.”
Martha has known this man for nine years and has never once asked what he does all day.
“Can I show you?”
What Theo does all day
When a product is approved the studying doesn't stop, it changes shape. That stage is called Phase IV, and it's the part of the pipeline almost nobody knows exists. Reports come in from doctors, pharmacists, parents, anyone. Theo codes each one, stacks it against every other report for that product worldwide, and looks for a shape that shouldn't be there. Nobody in his building is paid to prove a product is safe. They're paid to find the thing that says it isn't.
He tells her about a vaccine called RotaShield.
Licensed in August 1998, the first rotavirus vaccine in the United States, and rotavirus was putting a lot of babies in hospital. Then reports arrived of a serious bowel obstruction in infants who'd been vaccinated. Fifteen of them. Not fifteen thousand. Fifteen. In July 1999 the CDC told doctors to stop. In October the advisory committee voted it out and the manufacturer withdrew it. It was suspended within a year of licensure.
“The trials weren't big enough to catch something that rare,” Theo says. “No trial that size could be. That's not a scandal, it's math. So we keep counting after approval. And when the count said stop, it got stopped.”
He turns the monitor toward her. On the screen is a drug label, and near the top is a box with a heavy black border.
“Do you know how a warning gets into that box?” Martha doesn't.
“Somebody in a job like mine found it, after approval. Sometimes years after.” He lets it sit. “That box isn’t proof the system missed something. It's the receipt for the system catching it.”
Martha is quiet for a while. Then: “So it isn't gone. It's just been quiet.”
“Quiet because enough of us were covered, it’s like a row of matches in a row. The matches are susceptible people, and if you light one they’ll keep passing the flame on. But, remove big chunks and eventually that fire stops. The gap is the vaccine working.”
From somewhere near the sink, Sam the Skeptic asks the only question he ever asks. “What would it take to change your mind?”
He isn't asking Martha. He's asking the room, and he's asking you.
Martha doesn't answer tonight. She goes home still holding the post in one hand and a story about fifteen babies in the other, and both of them feel true, which is the honest place most people actually live. The claim is still standing when the door closes. But Martha didn't reshare anything on Facebook.
The move to keep
The difference between Option A and B wasn't knowledge. Theo knew exactly the same things in both. The difference was four moves, and the first one was silent: he checked his own motive, asked what she was frightened of instead of what she'd read, looked at her source with her rather than at her, and then said something true that cost him something.
That's the OPEN card. Run it before the facts, because facts handed to somebody who feels cornered don't land, they bounce, and sometimes they bounce straight into a share button.
Notice where Theo actually beat Bias the Brain, though. Not at Martha. In himself, in the two seconds where he caught what he wanted and named it. Bias survives on being invisible. The moment you catch yourself thinking, it loses its grip, and that works whether the brain you're checking is theirs or your own.
If you want to practice it somewhere it doesn't cost you a family member, that's the whole point of Stay in the Room. Someone you love believes something wrong, and the game is changing their mind without losing them, try it here, Stay in the room.
Rare isn’t gone. Rare is the vaccine doing its job. Wednesday we take the claim apart properly, gently, with the receipts.
Refer a friend
Somebody at your table is quietly deciding this one right now. Send them Option B, and start your Series 1 set.
This week's Plain Talk covers the same topic in plain language.
Thursday you get the full evidence so you can check my work. Written by a clinical researcher, free, at RootToRx.com. Read it this week after opting In: Opt-in Instructions
For educational purposes only. Nothing in this newsletter is medical advice. Talk to your doctor before making any health decision.
Instagram: instagram.com/roottorx | LinkedIn: linkedin.com/company/roottorx | Facebook Lab: facebook.com/groups/theroottorxlab | Subscribe: RootToRx.com
You are receiving this because you subscribed at roottorx.com.
Disclosure: Root to Rx is published independently by Open Label Media LLC. Views expressed are personal views of Justin Yamashita and do not represent his employer or any affiliated organization. No employer resources or proprietary information are used. Every claim is sourced from publicly available materials.
Root to Rx | 228 Park Ave S, #29976, New York, New York 10003, United States